Order outside the EU? Then the calculation of shipping costs, VAT, and duties is not correct!
Ordering from outside the EU? eBay invoices the VAT and import duty on the invoice due. Handy!
Only... eBay does that not correctly and not consistently.
Analysis 1:
As an example for this analysis, three products were used that fall under one eBay category for which the duty, according to customs, should be 0%.The correct “VAT and duty” rules for the relevant product category are listed here:
In other words:
- VAT (NLBTW) = 9.000%
- Third country duty (103) = 0.000%
Examples of three identical types of products in the same category:
- Item 1: The sale price was US $814,00. The duty according to eBay was US $25.63.
- Item 2: The sale price was US $364,99. The duty according to eBay was US $52.71.
- Item 3: The sale price was US $285,00. The duty according to eBay was US $0.00.
In other words:
- Item 1 with a higher sale price had a lower duty than Item 2 with a lower price.
- Item 3, with duty $0.00, is in the same category as Item 1 and Item 2.
- Item 1 and Item 2 show incorrect duty. This should also have been US $0.00.
- Item 3 does show the correct duty.
Analysis 2
According to the “VAT and duty” rules, you calculate the VAT and duty as follows:
- Duty is determined by taking the duty percentage of the sum of the “product + shipping costs” (for the products above, that percentage is 0% of the sum)
- Then you calculate the VAT by taking the VAT percentage of the sum of the “product + shipping costs + duty” (for the products above, that percentage is 9% of the sum)
- On top of that, customs handling fees are added (usually between 12 and 20 euros).
Below are two examples of the same invoice due:
- the invoice as shown on ebay.nl
here the item is shown with VAT included - the same invoice as shown on ebay.com
here the item is shown without VAT included
the VAT is listed separately - On both ebay.nl and ebay.com, there is no way to trace the official “VAT and duty” calculation as stated.
- Furthermore, the overviews between ebay.nl and ebay.com are not consistent. The amounts are completely different.
- That on ebay.nl the VAT is included in the item price and the duty is shown separately cannot be right. The duty must be calculated before the VAT is added to the item price.
I asked eBay eight times to explain the above. They could not explain it. They gave several possible reasons such as:
- eBay: the seller uses the wrong category, which can make the duty different
That was not the case, since the three items mentioned above were all in the same category (see analysis 1). - eBay: you can request a refund for duty charged in error (but you do have to pay first and wait until the item has been delivered)
I had done that, including sending reminders. I never got a response after that. Also, that was not an explanation for my observation. - eBay: unfortunately we cannot give you insight into the formula that was applied because we cannot see it.
I had asked them for the calculation showing how the invoice was put together.
In the end, eBay staff no longer wanted to discuss it. In other words, something is clearly not right, and eBay does not want to investigate it and, if necessary, adjust it.