Return Italy - Germany
Summary: kluhtu reports on a problematic sale of an iPhone to Italy, where the buyer claims the device was defective upon receipt. Despite being willing to take it back and trying to get a return label, kluhtu runs into difficulties, especially since the buyer’s tax ID is required. verena@ebay supports him with advice on sending the return shipping costs via PayPal and filing a dispute. After an unsuccessful appeal with eBay and the realization that the device and the money are lost, kluhtu finally files a police report. Several discussion participants warn about the risks of selling abroad.
Hello everyone,
I hope the wisdom of the crowd can contribute something to my case.
So I sold my iPhone to Italy, the phone was always treated carefully and worked perfectly. But when it arrived in Italy with the buyer, he only sent a picture with the charging cable connected, the screen was black and said he wanted to return it because it no longer works.
So this picture is absolutely not meaningful, because plug it in and then turn the screen off, well, okay.
I accepted the return, being clueless as I am, and then wanted to buy a return label via eBay or Parcel2Go. But then I end up on eBay Italy and there it shows me there are no open returns, so I can't buy anything either.
Then I tried to buy a label through DHL, GLS and UPS, but unfortunately I then need the buyer's personal tax number. Of course you can imagine that the guy won't give me his number.
Seems like a pretty simple scam to me…
eBay's German phone support helped as best they could and forwarded the request, but now the Italians are dealing with it, well and lo and behold, nothing is happening at all.
Now my iPhone is gone and I haven't received any money. Thanks for nothing, eBay.
So my question to the community: has anyone ever had a case like this, and if so how did they deal with it?
ok-gamerslog
I’m on same boat that I cannot generate return label. What will happen now?
perfect-sally
Either you do some research, e.g. on Google, because others have already managed it too, or you send the buyer the return shipping costs in advance. However, that doesn't work through eBay.
Option: you refund without a return shipment! It would make more sense if they would finally listen to us and not have things shipped abroad. That would avoid a whole lot of problems.
kluhtu
OPSo to all eBay users, it’s no longer enough to read the T&Cs, but also all forum posts…
Sentences like this are incredible:
Blaming the users for the mistake instead of eBay doing something about it, top 👍🏻
perfect-sally
Oh yeah? Who ships abroad then? Ebay or the sellers?
What should ebay do if, despite the "warnings," private sellers continue to ship abroad? Who is responsible for shipping then?
A: ebay?
B: the seller?
kluhtu
OPWhere on earth is there a “warning”?
It’s just a simple option field in the app that says “Offer international shipping,” plus there’s also a fee overview and that’s it.
petersmodellbahnstuebchen
Hi @kluhtu
the tip from @perfect-sally , which you’re quoting, is completely correct.
Selling abroad is just inherently risky, and that’s something that gets pointed out here in the forum again and again, as many problems reported by other users show.
Even I, as a commercial seller, only sell within Germany anymore, because, among other reasons, I don’t want to deal with the foreign eBay companies,
Best wishes from the Baltic Sea
Peter
kluhtu
OPHello @petersmodellbahnstuebchen ,
I'm totally fine with that too, but honestly, in the app it's just one click. Anyone who has had any experience with that, like I have, would also say next time, no way.
But you can't expect a user to read through every forum about all sorts of sales platforms or ask Dr. Google about everything and everyone.
In my opinion, the problem lies with eBay, with the way they handle such cases, because looking at it objectively. I cooperated and sent the buyer €55 via PayPal; that's also documented in the case. Then I even filmed myself 15 minutes later opening the package, and still the buyer was ruled in favor of without any questions, etc.
So if that had happened in Germany, how would the case decision have turned out then? The reasoning was, after all, that the package was successfully delivered, full stop.
petersmodellbahnstuebchen
Hi @kluhtu
believe me, I do empathize with you.
But first of all, the problem is that neither you nor I can prove what we actually sent or later got back. No platform in the world can objectively judge what really happened. Despite all the photos or video evidence.
However, when selling within Germany, I have, for one thing, much more scope linguistically to get help from eBay if there are problems.
And the fact is that the "buyer protection" on all sales platforms is now set very high. As a seller, but also as a buyer, that often leaves you only the out-of-court route. And if I were to take that route at all, I would want to do so exclusively in Germany.
Best regards from the Baltic Sea
Peter
sunrise1605
Yeah, that super easy sale abroad.
Who doesn’t know it .....
oskar_der_wikinger
Just a very basic question @kluhtu
did you write down the IMEI number of your iPhone?
Since, as a private individual, you sold the Apples for more than €2500 within four weeks, you must also be able to assign the corresponding device, after all.
kluhtu
OPHello,
there won’t be any more sales abroad after that, I’ve definitely learned that from this.
yes, we sold all the old iPhones and documented the IMEI or serial number as well.
Because I still have concerns that when the return process is underway, the iPhone will end up being deliberately destroyed, parts removed, the iPhone swapped out, or that I’ll even receive an empty package.
But let’s wait and see what else the case brings in the coming days.
verena@ebay
Hello @kluhtu ,
thank you very much for your post!
Accepting the return request was the right way in this case. As I can see, you’re also making a lot of effort on your side to take care of the reversal.
I would also advise you, just like @perfect-sally , to send your buyer the amount of the return shipping costs. To do this, you can message your buyer and ask for their PayPal address, for example. In this way, you show your willingness to resolve the issue together with your buyer, and you increase your chances in the event that your buyer files a Buyer Protection claim.
You can then also prove the payment of the costs to your buyer using the relevant bank statements.
Kind regards
Verena
kluhtu
OPHello,
I already wrote to the buyer to ask whether he can provide me with his PayPal address, let's see what comes of it.
I'm curious to see whether the issue gets resolved and whether, in the end, I don't end up receiving an empty package and still not getting my money.
Thanks for the help first of all!
verena@ebay
Great, so you’ve done everything you can do for now, and now it’s a matter of waiting. 🙂
If, when you receive the return, you notice that something isn’t right, please report it directly to eBay Italy so that this can be taken into account when the case is being processed. Feel free to get back in touch with us here as well, so we can keep an eye on it and also leave the appropriate notes for the colleagues at eBay Italy to support you from our side.
Kind regards
Verena
kluhtu
OPHello @verena@ebay ,
after letting the grass grow over this for 2 weeks now, because mentally my iPhone definitely isn’t coming back and I also didn’t want to receive any more money, I still wanted to explain the current status here.
Namely, eBay closed the case in the buyer’s favor, meaning the money and iPhone are gone, even though I paid €55 for return shipping and, shortly after UPS arrived at my place, I even filmed myself opening the package.
None of that mattered, so there’s absolutely no point in “proactively” cooperating.
As a last resort, I opened an appeal against the case decision. After that, I got an email from eBay saying I have to report it to the police.
I’ve naturally done that now too, because cooperation is supposedly rewarded. But as I said, mentally I’m done with the issue because eBay certainly won’t provide any compensation, unlike PayPal buyer protection.
What do we learn from this? Yes, don’t sell internationally as a private seller, because eBay doesn’t care about you.
If you can still somehow intervene or have any info about the case, I’d be really interested.
verena@ebay
Hello @kluhtu ,
Thank you very much for your feedback!
Great that you reported the incident to the police.
The case is currently with the expert team for approval of the objection due to the high value. If the responsible team sees no reason to reject your objection, it will be approved and a full payout will be made to you. Processing usually takes up to 48 hours. You will then receive an email with the result.
I’m keeping my fingers crossed that the result turns out positively for you. 🍀
Kind regards
Verena
perfect-sally
The first mistake was selling to Italy, or abroad at all, as a private seller!
And if eBay Italy is responsible now, then you've pretty much already lost, namely both the money and the goods.
You have to pay the return shipping, and they don't care how you do it. You could transfer the amount to the buyer or send it via PayPal, but no one guarantees that they’ll actually send it back then. Also because no one can see that you paid for the return shipping, since that only happens outside the system.
Maybe an eBay employee can still give you some advice, she’ll get in touch here.
@verena@ebay could you please take a look? Thanks