Purchase from private individual, compensation for value | Members help members

speikii · 2026-04-16T11:01:30.619000Z

Hello,I bought a gold pocket watch at auction, purchase price over 2000 euros.The glass was missing.After I found out the price for a new crystal, I decided to sell the watch, or rather the case with the covers marked as Gold585, because a repair would be too expensive.I dismantled the pocket watch and sent the gold-containing case to a dealer.After inspection, he told me that the material value was 345 euros.In terms of weight, that was in no way in line with the current market value.I informed the seller of the result.At the same time, I opened an eBay buyer protection case, item does not match the description.After a few days I received a Hermes return labelThe watch was returned in dismantled condition.After receipt and inspection, the seller was not pleased with the condition,but afterwards he transferred the full amount back to me.Not through buyer protection, but by him.The case was closed.A few days ago, I received a letter from a lawyer in this matter, demanding that I pay damages of 800 euros,with an enclosed quote from a workshop.There was also an expert opinion from a watch dealer stating that it is Gold 585.Since I assume that the seller acted commercially here, does a claim for compensation apply here?I was not informed about the right of withdrawal.The seller mainly deals in old, high-priced pocket watches and orders (militaria)Around 20 reviews per month.Perhaps someone has experienced something similar.I don't want legal advice, just opinions on the topic.Thank you

Discussions

Purchase from private individual, compensation for value | Members help members | eBay Germany