Official report from a buyer – suspicion of abusive return request and request to complete the transaction outside of eBay
Summary: agarwood-kyara-com reports a problematic buyer on eBay who is trying to handle return processes outside the platform and has also tested the purchased item themselves. They ask eBay to review this behavior for possible abuse and request support so they can act correctly as a seller. perfect-sally recommends contacting eBay customer service and checks whether agarwood-kyara-com is operating as a private or commercial seller. bootyooty asks how the buyer got hold of personal contact details, but is told that the contact took place after the purchase.
eBay offers no way to report THIS!
Even the ASSistant fails COMPLETELY!
Subject: Official report of a buyer – suspicion of abusive return demand and request to complete the transaction outside of eBay
Dear eBay team,
I would like to report a buyer and ask for an objective review of their behavior in connection with several natural products purchased via eBay from the Kyara agarwood category.
1. Communication outside the eBay platform
The buyer contacted me via WhatsApp and brought up further handling of the matter there. In doing so, they suggest a private settlement or processing via PayPal, instead of having the matter resolved exclusively through the предусмотренные eBay procedures.
I ask eBay to check whether this approach is compatible with the applicable policies and whether there is an abusive attempt to circumvent the platform's regular processes.
2. Buyer’s own handling and burning of the natural material
The attached WhatsApp messages explicitly show that the buyer examined the purchased wood themselves, broke open at least one piece, and tested material by lighting it or burning it.
This is therefore not merely a visual inspection of the delivered goods. The buyer made their own modifications to the natural material in order to assess its properties through their own tests.
This fact is essential for assessing any later return request. The original condition of the processed pieces may have been altered by these actions.
I therefore expressly ask eBay to take these documented actions into account when reviewing any possible return or refund request.
3. Allegation of forgery and subsequent return request
The buyer expresses the suspicion that the material purchased may not be authentic Kyara or Kynam. At the same time, they state in their communication that they cannot scientifically prove this suspicion.
Nevertheless, they are requesting a reversal or refund.
I consider it necessary to distinguish between a factually justified complaint and a return request based on the buyer’s own test results, which have not been independently verified. I dispute that the buyer’s stated assumption, on its own, constitutes proof that the delivered goods were incorrectly described or not authentic.
I therefore ask eBay to review whether the specific demand is objectively justified and whether the buyer’s behavior violates the applicable policies on buyer conduct or the return and buyer protection system.
4. Available evidence and previous sales history
For documentation purposes, I am attaching screenshots of the WhatsApp communication as well as screenshots of the eBay feedback and purchase history available.
The feedback documents earlier transactions and the buyer opinions submitted for them. I ask that this information be considered as additional context, without assigning it evidentiary value beyond its actual content.
5. My request to eBay
I ask for:
· review of the communication outside the platform and the handling proposed in it;
· review of the documented handling and burning of the natural material by the buyer;
· review of the subsequent return and refund demands with regard to possible abuse of the return or buyer protection system;
· information on how I should properly behave as a private seller in the event of an official return request or a buyer protection case.
I do not want to make any unproven claims and expressly leave the final assessment to eBay. However, I expect that the messages submitted and the buyer’s actions documented in them will be taken into account in the decision.
Available evidence
I am attaching to this report the relevant screenshots of the WhatsApp communication as well as additional screenshots of the eBay feedback available. Further documents, in particular the original item listings and proof of sale, can be provided if needed.
Thank you for reviewing this and for your support.
Kind regards
bootyooty
Mentor@agarwood-kyara-com
hey, where did the buyer get your phone number to be able to contact you via WhatsApp?
On eBay, data is only exchanged once something has been bought and paid for. So you’d be just as at fault if you passed on data yourself.
edit: got it… all of that only happened after the sale
https://www.ebay.de/help/policies/rules-policies-buyers/grundsatz-zu-missbruchlichem-kuferverhalten?id=4374&srsltid=AYCX9vLKTfqdYxjFUU2RuQxqCPUKDn6cSajpDFuoQAJA8hdZm4pPD9xP
perfect-sally
MentorI didn’t read your novel all the way through, but this is a community with users and not ebay support.
Contact customer service!
And think again about your seller status! I don’t see any private trading from you with 76 active listings and everything BRAND NEW! That can get expensive!
You typically act as an entrepreneur or commercial seller if you:
buy items to resell them
sell items you made for resale
regularly sell large quantities of items
sell similar goods over a longer period of time, especially new goods
frequently sell new items that you did not purchase for your own use
According to case law, indicators of commercial activity include:
maintaining an eBay shop
number of current sales: if many items are being sold continuously over a longer period of time, this is usually considered a commercial seller
ongoing sale of a private collection stretched over years
type of items sold (new or used goods, value): the sale of several similar navigation devices was classified as proof of commercial activity – as was the offer of 250 batteries in various sizes with reference to the availability of larger quantities.
a website or the use of promotional descriptions that make a professional impression
Note: We regularly review the trading activities of our sellers and may ask them to mark their eBay account as a business account. You should also expect to be sent a costly warning letter by competitors or consumer protection associations and to face legal action for an injunction.