Return at eBay received, but neither item nor refund received / financial loss of 630 eur
Summary: A participant, jaml-5744, expresses dissatisfaction in the eBay forum with the handling of a return case in which a sold iPhone 16 Pro was not returned, even though the buyer got their purchase price refunded. Despite jaml-5744 providing correct addresses, the iPhone was sent to an old address. meinehexe11 and bootyooty advise contacting customer service and ask questions about updating the address. In the end, an eBay employee confirms that there was an error when creating the return label and offers a refund as a gesture of goodwill. jaml-5744 repeatedly points out that all addresses were updated and thanks everyone for the support.
Official complaint and appeal against the decision in the return case – iPhone 16 Pro / financial loss of €630
Order number: 13-15184-81067
Item: Apple iPhone 16 Pro, 256 GB, Black Titanium
Purchase price: €630
DHL tracking number: 00340434317659706611
Dear Sir or Madam,
I am hereby formally complaining about the handling of my return case so far and would also like to ask for a renewed, thorough review of the decision.
I am contacting you because I now find myself in a situation where the buyer has received the full purchase price of €630 back, while my sold iPhone has still not been returned to me, despite the supposedly completed return shipment.
What is especially disappointing to me is that I have already contacted eBay customer service several times, explained all the circumstances, and provided the relevant evidence, but so far I have not been able to reach a satisfactory resolution.
1. Background of the sale and return
I sold an Apple iPhone 16 Pro on eBay.
After the sale, the buyer initiated a return.
Of course, I was prepared to accept the return shipment and handle the process properly.
My current and correct return address is in Leipzig.
So that the buyer could return the item without any problems, I personally provided him with a return label in the form of a QR code via the eBay messaging system.
This expressly included my correct Leipzig address.
In addition, I informed the buyer of my current address in writing.
I therefore fulfilled my duty to cooperate and provided the necessary information for a proper return.
2. Return sent to an address that has not been valid for three years
Despite the return option I provided, the buyer did not send the iPhone back to my current address in Leipzig.
Instead, the parcel was sent to my former residential address in Kolkwitz.
I have not lived at that address for three years already.
The buyer then sent me a screenshot of the DHL return label used, which in fact shows my old address in Kolkwitz.
The return label I provided with the correct Leipzig address was not used by the buyer.
However, the buyer claims that he received the label he used directly from eBay. He assures me that he neither entered nor changed the address himself.
3. Contradictory information about the return label
Because of this situation, I contacted eBay customer service by phone.
During that call, I was explicitly told that eBay had provided the buyer with a return label showing my correct current address in Leipzig.
However, this statement directly contradicts the buyer’s information and the shipping label he submitted.
I would like to emphasize that I also provided the buyer with a correct return label.
So to the best of my knowledge, the correct return data was available.
I therefore urgently ask eBay to check from the stored data which return label was actually created by eBay and made available to the buyer.
Only then can it be clarified how my address, which has not been valid for years, could have been used at all.
4. Alleged delivery by DHL without permission to leave the parcel
The further course of the return is especially problematic.
According to the official DHL tracking, the parcel was allegedly successfully delivered on 17.10.2026 at 13:26.
However, the delivery location was listed only as “parcel drop-off location”.
According to the tracking, delivery took place in 03099 Kolkwitz and therefore not at my current residential address in Leipzig.
I would like to explicitly point out that I did not give permission for parcel drop-off at this former address.
Since I have not lived there for three years, I had neither the opportunity to receive the parcel in person nor could I check where the parcel was supposedly left.
I have still not received the iPhone back.
In my view, an electronic delivery notice stating “parcel drop-off location” does not mean that the return shipment actually reached me.
I therefore ask that this circumstance also be taken into account in the review.
5. Refund to the buyer despite missing return shipment
By now, eBay has closed the return case and refunded the buyer the full purchase price of €630.
As a result, I am in an extremely unsatisfactory situation:
The buyer has received a full refund of the purchase price.
The iPhone was sent to the wrong address, which has not been valid for three years.
DHL shows a drop-off for which I did not give permission.
I have not received my iPhone back.
As a result, I have suffered a financial loss of €630.
I cannot understand why I should bear this loss even though I provided the correct return address.
6. Previous communication with eBay customer service
I have already contacted eBay customer service several times to clarify the situation.
In a written reply, I was informed that the original return case had been closed in favor of the buyer because I had not initiated the corresponding return process within the specified period of five days.
I do not want to leave this explanation unaddressed.
However, my current concern relates in particular to the misdirected return shipment and the whereabouts of my property.
Even if the original return case was closed due to a missed deadline, it still remains unclear why the item was sent to the wrong address and why I did not get it back.
In addition, I was informed in writing that the return label I provided had been sent outside of eBay and that the corresponding communication could therefore not be traced.
I would like to correct this statement explicitly.
I provided the return label, or rather the QR code, to the buyer via the eBay messaging system.
The corresponding communication should therefore be traceable within the eBay system.
I ask you to take these messages into explicit consideration during the renewed review.
7. Request for a renewed review and referral to the responsible specialist department
I would like to ask eBay, politely but firmly, not to assess my case solely on the basis of the original return decision.
Rather, I am requesting an independent review of the misdirected return shipment and the resulting financial loss.
In particular, I ask you to review the following points:
The return label originally provided by eBay, including the stored recipient address.
The DHL return label actually used by the buyer.
The correct Leipzig return address and QR code that I sent via the eBay messaging system.
The phone information from your customer service stating that the eBay return label contained my correct Leipzig address.
The DHL tracking and the alleged delivery to a parcel drop-off location in Kolkwitz.
The question of why the buyer received a full refund even though the item did not reach me again.
The possibility of reimbursing my financial loss under eBay’s seller protection or through a renewed case decision.
I would very much appreciate it if my request could be forwarded to the responsible specialist department or an appropriately authorized person.
8. My request for a fair solution
I have a great deal of understanding that eBay must observe certain policies and deadlines in return cases.
Nevertheless, I hope that the special circumstances of this case will also be taken into account.
I provided the correct return address, supplied a corresponding return label, and made repeated efforts to resolve the matter.
Still, I now have neither my iPhone nor the corresponding sale proceeds.
I therefore expressly request a renewed review of the case decision and reimbursement of my financial loss in the amount of €630.
If reimbursement by eBay is not possible, I ask for a detailed written explanation as well as information on what further options are available to me.
I would like to resolve this matter together with eBay in a fair and objective manner.
I would therefore be very grateful if you could personally take up my case again and help me clarify the matter.
Thank you for your time, your understanding, and your support.
Kind regards
Jana Müller
Order number: 13-15184-81067
DHL tracking number: 00340434317659706611
Available evidence:
Screenshot of the return label used by the buyer with the wrong address
DHL drop-off receipt
DHL tracking showing delivery to a parcel drop-off location
eBay messages with the buyer
QR code provided by me with the correct Leipzig address
Written reply from eBay customer service
miriam@ebay
Hello @jaml-5744 - I have good news for you! Our re-review is now complete and we were able to confirm that an error on our side happened when the return label was created. That’s why we’ve decided to refund you the full amount as a gesture of goodwill. The refund has already been manually initiated.
I’m sorry that you had so much trouble with this case and that resolving it took several attempts. All the more I’m glad that we were able to sort out the situation now 😊.
Best regards
Miriam
jaml-5744
OPI thank you / y'all from the bottom of my heart ♥️
miriam@ebay
Hello @jaml-5744 - thank you very much for your detailed description. I have passed your case on for a renewed review so that we can specifically understand the creation of the return label and the misdirected return.
Regardless of that, I’d like to ask you to directly update the old return address still stored in your eBay account. It is important to always keep all address details up to date so that such problems can be avoided in future.
As soon as I have a response, I’ll get back to you here.
Thanks for bringing this in, @bootyooty !
Kind regards
Miriam
jaml-5744
OPThanks for your reply. Very kind. Yes, everything has already been changed there.
bootyooty
Mentor@miriam@ebay ♥️ can you help out here somehow after you've done some research and looked into it? Thanks
jaml-5744
OPThe address has been changed. I sent you a correct address or rather a correct shipping label. But he claims he got the wrong one. He also sent me a screenshot showing eBay clearly indicating that the wrong address is on it. I called eBay; they sent him the correct label and he simply took a wrong one. No idea where he got that from. I don’t live at the address where it was sent, and I also had a leave-at-door authorization for that address or for my current one. I think the buyer is messing with me and eBay. From the very beginning there was trouble. He also claimed that the phone only has 125 GB, which is also not true; it was a contract phone, and those always come with at least 265 GB. The fact is, he has the money and the phone is at a drop-off location where neither I nor eBay or he sent it. @miriam@ebay
bootyooty
MentorSorry @jaml-5744 if he sends you a screenshot showing the wrong address, the question remains: where would he have gotten it from if not from eBay itself?
Miriam will reply as long as she isn’t already off for the day, otherwise you’ll have to wait until tomorrow.
jaml-5744
OPYes, thanks 🙏🏼 I also called eBay several times. They also told me that my correct address is verified in the system. And they can’t explain why he has a return label with the wrong address. But in the screenshot he sent me, my wrong old address is definitely there. And I also don’t know how a permission to leave it could come about. In any case, the package is now somewhere at the old address. And the post office isn’t commenting on it either. Now the buyer has got the full refund back, my phone is gone. And I have nothing at all :(
bootyooty
MentorMost users also partly don't even know that if they move, they don't just have to change one address, but all @jaml-5744 did you explicitly also have here under return address
https://accountsettings.ebay.de/uas/addresses
is the current one there?
About the drop-off location: You wrote above "and also I had a drop-off authorization for this address or for my current one."
It says there that you had one, or was it a typo and was supposed to mean no?
bootyooty
MentorSo I was right again... you didn't change the return address in your eBay account, and as a result your buyer got that address.
jaml-5744
OPNo, the address has already been changed for a long time. Even when I had called eBay, they didn’t know how he could get to my old address.
bootyooty
MentorCan't have been long ago at all, @jaml-5744 because Miriam wrote here an hour ago that you should do that, or is an hour a long time for you?
jaml-5744
OPOh sorry, no I naturally didn't have permission to leave the package either for the old or the new address. In both addresses it's in an apartment building where several parties live.
bootyooty
MentorNext point: In the listing, the item location was stated as Berlin, but the return was then supposed to go to Leipzig? 🤔
Also, 6.19 DHL parcel was stated, DHL only ever covers losses up to 500 euros anyway, you should have booked additional insurance, okay that doesn't help now anymore.
I don't know who could still help now, since quite a few things seem to have gone wrong.
The biggest problem seems to be solving this:
Screenshot of the return label used by the buyer with the wrong address
That leaves the question of where the buyer got your wrong address from. I'm assuming that somewhere in your ebay account you still had the old address stored.
bootyooty
MentorAddendum:
The label was created on 13/10 at 17:57
Just 10 minutes later, at 18:07, a drop-off location was booked, by whom?
As far as I know, only the recipient can do that.
So you should have been able to see on 13/10 in the shipment tracking where the journey was going and take action accordingly?
bootyooty
MentorCheck @jaml-5744 have you checked ALL the addresses?
https://accountsettings.ebay.de/uas/addresses
Also the return address in your eBay account?
Where would a buyer even have your old address from? They can only send it to what’s on the label; a 3-year-outdated address no buyer can know, unless they knew you used to live there, which I’d find unusual.
meinehexe11
MentorHey, hey @jaml-5744
you’re here in the public eBay forum. Since we can’t help you, we definitely won’t read the whole text either (at least I won’t) Contact customer service.