Return without communication
Summary: black_forester_2026 faced a dilemma when a buyer returned an item without prior communication. They sought advice on whether to refuse the parcel or accept it. gebraucht-ist-gut advised against refusing the package, suggesting to instead document the package's condition. It was noted that the return had a different tracking number, indicating the buyer paid for the return themselves. turbotuentchen suggested reviewing eBay's buyer and seller protection policies. black_forester_2026 expressed concern about being compelled to issue a refund despite selling as a private seller with no return policy, but remained open to checking the returned item.
Hi everyone,
I’m currently facing a bit of a tricky situation and hope for your advice and experience reports. Last week I sold and shipped an item as a private seller. The buyer also accepted the package according to the DHL app. But just one day later I see in my DHL app that the item has been sent back by him and that the package will arrive with me on Monday. The buyer has neither contacted me nor opened an eBay case.
So now I’m wondering: What’s the best way to proceed in such a case? Refuse acceptance or accept the package?
black_forester_2026
OPThe issue has been resolved. This post can now be deleted. Many thanks to everyone who helped me.
black_forester_2026
OPCan you also chat directly with an eBay employee on eBay?
turbotuentchen
MentorNo, chatting only with the chatbot
Employees only call back, or you call the phone number listed in the imprint.
black_forester_2026
OPAlright. what do you think I should do in this situation? I’m a private seller and I’m actually not obliged to take the item back. Also, the buyer hasn’t contacted me and hasn’t opened an eBay case either in which he explains a reason for it. As already written, I can see in my DHL app a parcel addressed to me from his town.
turbotuentchen
MentorDifferent rules apply on eBay. In the help pages you can search for buyer and seller protection and read it in detail. Take a look at what the buyer is sending back.
Refusing acceptance has already been explained to you, it’s not an option.
black_forester_2026
OPI read it. I’ll just take a look at what the buyer sent back to me. But it’s still pretty interesting to simply return the item in a private sale, where any right of return is excluded. That basically forces a refund on you. But thanks for your replies, that’s very kind of you :-) I’ll get back to you as soon as I have any news
petersmodellbahnstuebchen
MentorNo,
however, during business days you can chat here in the forum with an eBay employee or ask the chatbot in the help section to request a callback from an eBay employee.
black_forester_2026
OPBest to film me taking it out of the parcel locker and unpacking it. Better safe than sorry. Who knows what he sent me back. The whole thing is kind of weird. If you think I shouldn't refuse the delivery, then I'll do it that way.
gebraucht-ist-gut
MentorWell, if it’s sent back with the same tracking number, he can’t actually have opened it, I’d assume.
Refused acceptance would also be visible in the scan then.
It’s also possible there was an error on DHL’s end.
Right now everything is pretty vague.
Sometimes the outbound shipping costs are just gone.
If he doesn’t contact you at all or opens a case, you could also (beforehand) issue a refund minus the shipping costs in the purchase details. (If the buyer was at fault)
black_forester_2026
OPit's a different tracking number, so he paid for a DHL label himself.
gebraucht-ist-gut
Mentoroh, I see,
you didn’t write that - it read as if exactly the package with the same number was being returned.
Then refusing to accept it is even worse, because in case of doubt eBay would decide in the buyer’s favor, since he has proof of return shipment.
Whether he is actually entitled to the return or not.
black_forester_2026
OPBy the way, the money was released to my Ebay account today
gebraucht-ist-gut
MentorHello @black_forester_2026 ,
Have you already messaged the buyer?
Refusing to accept it would at least also be the worst way.
In the event of a dispute with eBay, both the goods and the money would then be gone.
black_forester_2026
OPSince he didn’t respond to a “Thanks for your purchase” and “Your package is at your DHL branch” before either, I haven’t messaged him yet.