Behavior in the event of incorrect eBay decisions on intellectual property
Summary: herocustomparts had its eBay listings blocked due to an alleged intellectual property infringement and is looking for advice on how to proceed. A seller from England reported him because he uses parts that are publicly available. perfect-sally recommends registering as a business and adding the required information, while voli-maus emphasizes that no legal advice can be given and that herocustomparts should be patient. herocustomparts confirms that their 3D prints were created by them and are different.
What can I do, or how should I behave?
My listings were blocked by eBay because of an alleged infringement of intellectual property.
(https://www.ebay.de/itm/287260862987)
A seller from England reported me. At the EUIPO, he has registered a design that protects an assembly made up of two purchased parts:
https://euipo.europa.eu/eSearch/#basic/1+1+1+1/100+100+100+100/015111965
- an electrical pushbutton
- a 3-pin BMW connector
I myself used a different electrical pushbutton and also the BMW connector. Both parts are freely available and can be bought on eBay, for example.
The actual product in my listings is 3D-printed parts that are attached around the pushbutton in order to place it in the rear window of a BMW.
The electronics are only a means to an end and not part of the actual design. Later on, nothing of the electronics is visible anymore.
My appeal against this decision has already been rejected twice, each time without a specific reason. I was only told that I had violated the guidelines.
What further steps should I take now, or how should I behave?
What are the community's experiences and assessments of a case like this?
Thank you very much for your help!
voli-maus
Mentor"The actual product in my listings are 3D-printed parts that are attached around the button in order to place it in the rear window of a BMW."
Did you make the 3D prints yourself? @herocustomparts
No one may and will give you legal advice here.
Wait and see if anything else comes up.
herocustomparts
OPYes, they are fundamentally different too.
perfect-sally
MentorSo I’d advise you to register as a business first if, as an alleged private seller, you have the same items listed multiple times. And if the competition has already reported you, it can get a lot more painful for you when it hits your wallet and gets expensive.
And if you make or buy something to sell it, then that is clearly commercial trading.
herocustomparts
OPI took care of it right away. Thanks
perfect-sally
MentorNice, but you won’t be able to sell for long on ebay like this without a VAT ID. As soon as ebay finds out, the account will be restricted.
And legally required business information such as a right of withdrawal notice, sample cancellation form, terms and conditions (not mandatory but useful), privacy policy, and information on how things stand with your invoices are still missing.
And one more very important thing: as a business seller, no returns is not allowed at all!