Item violates eBay policy
Summary: The discussion is about a problem concerning the rejection of an item on a sales platform due to violations of policies that are not clearly defined. One participant, ef_dienste, notes that similar products are available from other sellers and criticizes the platform’s lack of transparency. An AI model that works statistically and does not produce consistent outputs is mentioned as a possible explanation for the platform’s behavior.
Hello everyone,
I hope someone from support or with similar experience can help me out.
Several of my listings for water beads/hydrogel gel balls were removed by eBay for an alleged violation of the product safety policy. These are ordinary hydrogel/water beads with full safety and warning information in the description and leaflet.
What’s interesting, though:
I reported a nearly identical item, which is still active and, according to eBay after review, does NOT violate the policies.
Item number:
187614456823
Title:
„Gel Blaster Kugeln Hydrogel Munition Für Gel Blaster Wasserperlen“
The listing also describes:
water beads
Gel Blaster ammunition
hydrogel balls
use as Gel Blaster ammunition
as well as similar item features and safety warnings like my removed listings.
eBay replied to me with:
„We have determined that the listing does not violate our policies.“
Now I’m honestly confused:
Why are my comparable listings being removed while nearly identical listings from other sellers remain allowed?
My removed listings had already been active for a long time, sold many times, and contained:
safety instructions
age warnings
warnings about choking hazards
correct description of use
In addition, I was even previously told that the removal could partly be due to automated checks/AI.
So my questions are:
Are there currently different evaluations depending on category/title?
Are such water beads/hydrogel balls currently allowed to be sold or not?
Which specific wordings or categories are permitted?
How can consistent review be ensured?
I naturally want to comply with the policies correctly, but I would appreciate decisions that are understandable and consistent.
Thank you in advance.
ef_dienste
I had a similar case. The same product is also available from other retailers. The criteria for the rejection are not transparent. All in all, the way this was handled shouldn’t be like this. In my view, there are better ways.
imperial-modellbau
Hello @Steffi @eBay
I would still really like to know how it can be that a 1 : 1 copied article gets deleted for one user and stays up for another ???
ef_dienste
If there is an AI model behind it, the explanation may be that these work statistically. A given input does not always produce the same output, but a similar output. That's how it is.
imperial-modellbau
Well @Steffi @eBay
explain THAT then, please! ! !
imperial-modellbau
Hello @l._a._g._guns_shop
just copy one of the other articles 1:1 and list it again (of course with your own pictures) !
Then you'll see what happens !
l._a._g._guns_shop
OPI already had that, they were removed too!
steffi@ebay
Hello @l._a._g._guns_shop, I can absolutely understand that the situation is frustrating and confusing for you — especially when comparable listings remain active while yours were removed. Especially with items that are similar in description, use, or safety labeling, that naturally seems contradictory at first glance.
However, unfortunately it is often difficult to make direct comparisons with other listings — even when the items appear very similar. 🔎 The reason is that the review does not look only at the visible title or product type, but also considers, among other things:
• the chosen category
• wording in the listing
• stored item specifics
• images
• safety-related information
• regulatory assessments
• as well as internal review mechanisms and risk classifications
As a result, two outwardly similar listings can be assessed differently. Active listings from other sellers unfortunately also do not automatically mean approval or general permissibility for comparable items. 🙏
So that the colleagues can take a closer look at your specific case, I’d like to ask whether you have already filed an appeal against the removal. If so, I would please need:
📄 the reference number of the appeal/case
🔢 and the item number(s) of the removed listings
Thanks in advance 🌟
l._a._g._guns_shop
OPHello @Steffi @eBay ,
even though I took over the item and description from others via "sell similar item", mine are still being removed, but the other seller's are not.
I have already filed an appeal for the items. Here are the requested items:
Reference no. 2-105294645770 eBay item no.:177991986047
Reference no. 2-103751072296 eBay item no.:177003726890
Reference no. 2-103897269129 eBay item no.:176952826774
Reference no. 2-103896187901 eBay item no.:177003692675
Thank you very much for the processing! 🙂
Best regards, Andreas
steffi@ebay
Hello Andreas @l._a._g._guns_shop, first of all, I’d like to apologize for my late reply. 🙏 Somehow the notification about the tags doesn’t seem to have reached me, so I unfortunately only saw the posts now.
Thanks also for sending the reference numbers and item numbers. 📄🔎
I understand your objection, especially if you took over the listing data via the “Sell similar item” function and the corresponding listings from other sellers are still active. However, in cases like this it’s unfortunately not always possible to make a direct comparison between different listings, since during a review numerous factors can be taken into account (as already mentioned) that are not visible from the outside.
So that the colleagues can better understand your note, could you please give me a specific item number for a comparable listing from another provider that, to the best of your knowledge, is still active and has not been removed?
Then the colleagues can better assess the point of comparison you mentioned.
Thanks for your support and your patience. 🌟
l._a._g._guns_shop
OPHello @Steffi @eBay
here are comparable listings:
eBay item no.:187614456823
eBay item no.:137287412997
eBay item no.:326450453090 over 100 sold!!!
eBay item no.:225856816861 over 100 sold!!!
eBay item no.:236817710920
eBay item no.:306466543418 98 sold!!!
eBay item no.:285897620018
The list could be much longer, as there are numerous comparable listings on eBay that are still active.
Against this background, I would like to ask for a re-review of my removed listings. Since the comparable listings I reported do not violate eBay guidelines after your review and my items are comparable in product type, material, use, and safety instructions, I find the different treatment difficult to understand.
I would therefore be happy if my removed listings were reviewed again and, if they comply with the applicable guidelines, reactivated.
Kind regards
Andreas
steffi@ebay
Hello Andreas @l._a._g._guns_shop, thank you very much for the additional information and the list of comparable listings. 🙏
I understand that, from your perspective, the situation is difficult to understand, especially when comparable listings are still active and in some cases already have a high number of sales.
Thank you also for compiling the corresponding item numbers. 📄🔎
I will forward the reference numbers you provided, the removed items, and the comparable listings you listed to the responsible colleagues for another review.
Please understand that I cannot preempt the outcome of such a review. However, the responsible teams will take the information available into account accordingly and reassess the matter once again.
steffi@ebay
Hello Andreas @l._a._g._guns_shop, thank you very much for your patience.
I have passed your case, including the reference numbers and comparable offers you mentioned, on to the responsible colleagues and have now received feedback on it.
It was determined that not all affected offers had an objection lodged against them. A new review can generally only be carried out for offers for which the regular objection process has already been completed. Since I rely on the information provided by members when handling such cases and trust its accuracy, it is of course important that the information submitted for this purpose is as complete and correct as possible.
Regardless of that, the matter was reviewed. According to the responsible specialist department, the removed offers unfortunately cannot be restored. The reason is that there is a product recall for the products offered. The removal of the offers therefore took place as part of the applicable product safety requirements and was assessed as correct.
I understand that this is particularly difficult to understand because you found comparable offers from other sellers and in some cases also used the "Sell similar item" function. However, active offers from other sellers unfortunately do not indicate whether an item is generally permitted or can remain on the marketplace permanently. The assessment of offers is always based on the information available in each case and the applicable requirements.
Even if this answer probably does not meet your expectations, I hope that the background is now somewhat easier to understand.
l._a._g._guns_shop
OPHello @Steffi @eBay
Thank you very much for reviewing my case again.
I respect the decision that my removed listings will not be restored. However, I still do not understand what the specific difference is between my removed listings and the comparable listings that are still active.
As part of my report, I mentioned the following listing that is still active, among others:
Item number: 187614456823
“Gel Blaster balls hydrogel ammo for Gel Blaster water beads”
In my assessment, this is a comparable product (hydrogel/water beads for Gel Blaster), which is still being offered on eBay.
I would therefore ask for a specific explanation:
Which specific characteristics of my listing led to its removal?
Which characteristics distinguish my listing from the comparable listing that is still active?
Does the removal refer to a specific manufacturer, a particular brand, or a specific recalled product?
Or does the removal apply in principle to all water beads/hydrogel beads of this kind?
My goal is to correctly understand the applicable requirements and to make future listings compliant with the law and in accordance with eBay policies.
I would be very grateful for a specific explanation of the differences between my listing and the aforementioned listing that is still active.
Kind regards
Andreas
Gel Guns Shop
steffi@ebay
Hello Andreas @l._a._g._guns_shop, I understand very well that you want a specific comparison between your removed listing and the still active comparison listing. Unfortunately, I can't break down such an individual detailed assessment for you in detail at this point.
After the review, it was confirmed that the removal of your listings took place in connection with the applicable product safety requirements and the product recall in question. The decision was therefore based not only on the general product type, but on the specific safety-related assessment of the affected listings.
For this reason, I unfortunately cannot confirm a different approval for comparable listings from other sellers. The fact that another listing is still active does not automatically mean that it was assessed identically in terms of content or in the review context.
I hope this gives you at least a little more guidance. Thank you for your understanding. 🌟
l._a._g._guns_shop
OPGood day steffi@ebay ,
how long does such a review usually take?
Best regards Andreas
imperial-modellbau
Sometimes it feels like it takes forever - which may be because the people checking it can't find the error.
The fact that there is a week between a question and no answer yet also suggests that those responsible themselves can't make sense of it.
I've often suggested that at least a status update be posted then - that way you don't feel quite so ignored - but unfortunately that doesn't seem to be of interest on eBay's side ! ☹️
der-sparpreis
Hey, mine was deleted too. No chance to change it even though it’s sold here 100 times over. It gets deleted completely randomly by AI and without any legal basis.
perfect-sally
@der-sparpreis
you still have quite a few articles online that are going to blow up in your face soon if AI keeps going like this.
der-sparpreis
Let's see what happens, with the airsoft guns that already happened, but then my objection went through. Not with the gel balls.
petersmodellbahnstuebchen
@Steffi @eBay , @vera@ebay
Hi Steffi, hi Vera,
could one of you take a look at this case.
I marked both of you, since I don’t yet know who will be here for the community this afternoon. Thanks, both of you. 🤗