Suggestions for improvement
TOPIC eBay suggestions for improvement:
There is plenty one could start with here without ever finding an end, unfortunately. I’ll go through point by point and mention what urgently needs to be changed -
1.)
One absolutely important point is/would be the immediate ending of PRIVATE SALES for free, because this no longer has anything to do with fair competition, and it increasingly promotes PRIVATE COMMERCIAL sellers who, God willing, may one day be sanctioned by the state under the platform transparency law, but what good does that do us someday? Something has to happen immediately, because at some point there will be no more commercial sellers on eBay and therefore no more eBay sales platform either.
Because, who is currently financing the whole system?? right, the commercial sellers, who are charged with all kinds of hidden costs/payments/commissions on every paid euro from the buyer, also on shipping, customs duties and country-specific taxes.
The PRIVATE COMMERCIAL sellers pay nothing at all, which means bought for 50€ and sold for 100€ puts 50€ cash in the pocket; for the reputable ones, a quick 30% of the 100€ goes away with listings, leaving at most 20€ that then still have to be taxed. Now, the bad thing about this process is not just this calculation, but that the PRIVATE COMMERCIAL sellers sell the same items as the commercial ones, whether old or new, retro, vintage or antique, and can offer them 20% cheaper and still have 50% more PROFIT than a commercial seller, i.e. 30€. The cardinal question now is: where does someone buy?? right, where it’s cheaper, so from the PRIVATE COMMERCIAL seller, and what happens?? right, the COMMERCIAL sellers go bust, and with them eBay too, and what happens to the PRIVATE COMMERCIAL sellers? at some point they’ll be billed by the state, have to pay VAT, income tax and fines, which often can’t be paid, with the consequence that they then go into personal insolvency, receive citizen's allowance, and then burden the state, does that strengthen the economy, the state?? No.
Now, eBay, this is not a unrealistic worst-case scenario but absolute near-term reality if you don’t react immediately, IMMEDIATELY.
There are PRIVATE COMMERCIAL sellers on eBay with 20,000 listings!!! TWENTY THOUSAND!!! enforce the legal requirements on all PRIVATE sellers immediately, 30 items and/or 2000€ per year. (collection liquidators, heirs, etc. excluded)
That is/would currently still be an anchor for all commercial eBayers, who are under eBay’s responsibility-
Change something - then something will change - if you change nothing - then nothing will change either
maybe once again it will be happily 3-2-1- yours and not soon 1-2-3 eBay is almost over
The 2nd point is coming, promised
have a nice weekend
Regards Oliver
trading-and-more
OPGood morning, on the topic of changes, improvements and/or an eBay survival proposal.
I’ll lay out a few commercial theses and/or thoughts here.
eBay has 18 million users, at least according to Google, of which certainly between 90-99 are private sellers, which works out to about 1-10% commercial sellers, or?? The exact number is maybe just under 5%, meaning 5% of the entire eBay family are paying the bill, so to speak, i.e. all the costs. Without the 5%, it would not be possible to keep eBay alive, or it is not possible, because nobody would pay the bill; the end would therefore be the logical consequence. Now the question arises whether it is legitimate, smart and forward-looking to keep squeezing exactly these 5% more and more, while letting the laughing 95% do their business on eBay for free. Is it smart to make those pay who should actually be living from it, meaning should earn their livelihood with eBay, while letting the others, who actually ONLY clear out their basement from time to time or sell their second son’s outgrown romper suit, get away with it for free, since they shouldn’t/needn’t earn anything?? A question I’m just putting out there.
It might be okay if it were only that, clearing out now and then etc., but unfortunately that is only the case in the rarest instances; PRIVATE COMMERCIAL sellers are sprouting up on a large scale who are taking advantage of exactly this gap and paying nothing, and are in unfair competition with commercial sellers who, under the guise of “private,” do EXACTLY the same thing as reputable commercial sellers and pay nothing and do not have to fulfill any of the obligations of a commercial seller. (Platform transparency law or not)
Does a private seller have to live off sales?? May they live off them?? certainly not
For us commercial sellers, it is existential; that means that this activity should provide our livelihood. Given these facts, the question is: would it be bad if a PRIVATE seller maybe paid 5.5% commission for their romper suit?? so then instead of 10€ proceeds they only get 9.45€?? No, it wouldn’t be!”
But if the 95%, i.e. the private sellers, pay commission again, and not 10% as before but 5.5%, and as part of that the reputable commercial sellers’ commission were also reduced from the current 11% to 5.5%, then in the end the costs of the entire bill would certainly be covered again (it’s not 5% paying 100% of the bill, but the 100% paying the 100% bill), and this would not only relieve those who have to live from it, but would also make the competition that has arisen between commercial and private sellers fairer again.
It would also separate the wheat from the chaff to some extent, meaning the PRIVATE COMMERCIAL sellers would rethink, because if they no longer have the direct unfair advantage - not having to pay commission - and must also face the threat of the state, then they will either operate properly as commercial sellers and/or stop.
Even if some then stop, quite rightly, that would not be bad because they should/must/may live from their activity, and the commercial sellers would sell more again, namely what those “quitters” no longer sell, and this would strengthen everyone: the commercial sellers, the eBay system and the state and the economy. In this context, one should also question whether it makes sense to want to expand worldwide sales for commercial sellers and, in return, charge sellers commissions on any possible taxes /duties/fees as well as on the worldwide expensive shipping costs. How do you justify imposing 11% commission on a reputable commercial seller for some luxury tax/fee in Papua New Guinea??
Every commercial seller, if they then decide to sell internationally, gets a surprise package of how much tax/customs duty/fee and shipping costs will apply in that country; I have already experienced a sale to South America where over 80€, shipping costs of 49.90€ as well as customs and tax of 21€ were incurred, meaning that of a total of 150.90€ - 11% commission plus VAT were due. Out of the original 80€ and an invoice amount of 150.90€, less than 60€ remained. In addition, it is a very big risk, because shipping also carries the risk of suffering a total loss, since if the buyer says the item was not received, what basically always happens is that the respective country decides in favor of the buyer, and one ends up almost always with a bad hand; eBay.de then says its hands are tied, eBay in such and such a country has decided this way and that.
I have already had the pleasure several times of trying to defend my rights with the country-specific eBay department in their languages.
Actually, I/we have a contract with eBay Germany and should be able to act with their help/support in such cases (regardless of what, when, where is written in hundreds of pages of terms and conditions or not), because after all eBay also decides what happens with OUR money, what is refunded, what is withheld, what is deducted and/or paid out.
I think that, due to the fact that everything abroad is subject to commissions, the very least one can expect is support in enforcing our rights, especially since in many cases we cannot view country-specific tracking, or are not familiar with the relatively poor delivery options due to possible local problems.
mmstore74
Hello everyone and a Happy New Year from me too.
I also have to write something about this @bootyooty which I, like @trading-and-more, don't think is fair.
Buyers can rate the following points
> Accurate description
How exactly is one supposed to define exact and inaccurate?
For example, selling a chair. A chair with 4 legs, a backrest, a seat, and the dimensions — is that exact?
> Appropriate shipping costs
If I read in some reviews here: shipped for 1.80 euros but 2.50 euros postage charged, and then it gets rated negatively, what's fair about that? The envelope costs money, printing a label or stamp costs money, and you also have to go to the post office or the nearest mailbox.
> Delivery time
If the seller ships on time with tracking number, what can the seller do if it is delivered late? That's a mystery to me, and they'd get a negative rating for it.
> Communication
I don't know whether it's possible the way I'm writing it now.
But how can it be that a buyer can rate communication that 99.9% of the time never even exists between buyer and seller?
Kind regards
Marc
mmstore74
@trading-and-moredid this apply to me?
Now to your statement, the PRIVATE individuals have registered a business, run only a PRIVATE account to save on commissions, hello, are you serious, how can you say something like that??
trading-and-more
OPno, I'm totally with you
mmstore74
@trading-and-more 😁👍
What I always find super funny, even if it is annoying:
When these sellers, who used to sell commercially and now sell privately, talk about liquidating collections, but you can see from their ratings that they keep buying items like crazy, even though they supposedly want to liquidate this collection, then I wonder why Ebay turns a blind eye to it
trading-and-more
OPYes, if it weren't so sad and true, it would be funny, but it is shameful how one is sometimes paraded around and laughed at as a system-conforming EBAYPROVISIONSZAHLER.
Well, that's life and reality, unfortunately
There are still countless situations that should be addressed, that need to be changed or reformed, but for me that won't be relevant in this life anymore; after 27 years, on 14.12.2024, right on time for the new regulation, it's over.
trading-and-more
OPMaybe now you can answer that for me, what I’d still like to point out here
2)
"Hello, I have a question that doesn’t really fit the topic, but maybe someone can explain to me why this exists and why. My question to eBay a long time ago was why there is commission on shipping costs. Answer: Yes, because there were sellers who charged €10 for the item and €20 for shipping, so eBay wanted to put the "smart" ones in their place and then also charged 11% commission on the shipping costs, right?? But at the same time, we commercial sellers were also restricted in the shipping costs, which means that in this or that category only up to so many euros shipping costs are allowed, so it was deceitfully claimed why commission is charged, while on the other hand it was or is no longer possible for most people to determine shipping costs themselves. Well, that’s eBay. I wrote in the line before, "most" does not mean all, there are so-called power sellers on eBay, without naming names, who enjoy the advantage of being able to determine their shipping costs themselves. I can/am not allowed to do that. Is there a two-tier system for commercial sellers?? Is that fair, is that just, NO it isn’t. There is a large seller who charges, and is also allowed to by eBay, who sells 500 items a day and charges up to €26.90 for a DHL package of maybe 8 kg, has a contract with DHL and probably pays €4.90 for each package, regardless of whether it’s 1 kg or 31.5 kg. For anyone quick with the math, that means 500x€5 = €2,500 a day, but it will certainly be more like €8-10 per package, so that’s daily !!! €4,000-5,000, mind you daily, so over a year, just like that, about 1-1.5 MILLION, now that’s something, right, good business idea, with support from eBay, and the buyer or buyers are the "FOOLS". Well, genius or madness, that is the question Regards"
mmstore74
@bootyooty
Uh? Why should I justify that? I’m just writing my opinion here, like many others.
Did I write that you should? Just asked if you’d be OK with it!
Yeah sure, if not YOU, then who’s supposed to issue warnings? Me as the buyer? Hardly.
Nobody wants that, but eBay could prevent this kind of inequality by bringing back “fairness” and charging the same fees for everyone, what’s so hard about that?
And NO, I don’t buy anything here for free or at no cost, after all I pay for the goods, and if you’re interested: 80% of my purchases are from commercial sellers.
Who or where did I write that you buy anything “FREE”? Do you even read the posts properly?
mmstore74
Good morning everyone,
@trading-and-moreI agree 1000%.
An absolutely important point is/would be the immediate end of PRIVATE SELLING for free, because this has nothing more to do with fair and honest competition,
The cardinal question now is where does someone buy?? Right where it’s cheaper, namely from the PRIVATE-COMMERCIAL
@bootyooty Sorry if I strongly disagree here... I’ve been on eBay since 2003 and even back then there were tons of private-commercial sellers. That didn’t stop these sellers back then from selling here either, and back then a sales commission had to be paid! That’s true, but back then EVERYONE had to pay sales commission, including the private-commercial sellers, and that’s different today and therefore not fair competition.
Would you think it was OK if everyone could shop for free but only you had to pay?
@bootyooty Can’t and shouldn’t every trader here send out warnings for antitrust violations?
You’d spend hours every day just issuing warnings to people.
I had saved about 100 commercial sellers; starting on 01/03/2023, 73 shops were closed within not even 2 weeks, and I found them one by one again as private sellers (you can tell from the pictures, etc.
They’re registered as commercial with the authorities, pay taxes, just no fees, and if you ever feel like it, calculate how much eBay lost from 01/03/2023 onward
bootyooty
Uh? Why should I justify that? I'm just writing my opinion here, like many others.
Yeah, sure, if not YOU, who’s supposed to send warnings then? Me as a buyer? Hardly.
And NO, I don’t buy anything here for nothing or for free, after all I pay for the goods and if you’re interested: 80% of my purchases are from commercial sellers.
So why are you only now getting worked up after over 1 1/2 years that private sellers don’t have to pay selling fees? 🤔
Will your prices then be cheaper if they had to? Or is your mistaken belief actually that fewer private sellers would sell here then? 😎
As far as I remember, the idea behind the eBay auction house was once that private sellers here would also be allowed to start auctions and sell.
That was a rhetorical question, I'm out of here; you don't want any other opinions or views, so then stay among yourselves.
=========>>>>>>>
trading-and-more
OP@bootyooty well, since you’re not a SELLER, it doesn’t really affect you, so you also can’t objectively and realistically assess what has happened to the COMMERCIAL sellers over the last 2 years, can you?? You can’t compare the situation from 20 years ago with today; that comparison is as off as the Earth to the Sun or the Pope to a brothel. It’s obvious that if everyone pays, trading is fairer, right?? and that’s not the case at the moment, is it?
Now to your statement: the PRIVATE sellers have registered a business, they only operate a PRIVATE account to save on commissions, seriously, are you even for real, how can you say something like that??
There are laws and they must be followed; if someone buys items with the intention of making a profit, then that is commercial activity, full stop. You say everything is fine, they have a business registration but sell PRIVATELY. Commercial also means acting accordingly and having to present and identify yourself externally; have you ever heard of an imprint, terms and conditions, tax number, tax ID, returns, cancellation policy, packaging register, WEEE number, ..... those are just a few of the things a commercial seller has to provide, apparently not. First of all, this is meant to inform buyers about their rights and make everything comply with the law. If you think everything is fine because the PRIVATE-COMMERCIAL sellers have a business registration, then ask yourself why there are PRIVATE and COMMERCIAL accounts on eBay; if, in your opinion, a business registration were enough, there certainly wouldn’t be COMMERCIAL accounts and everyone would run PRIVATE ones, right??
Arguments like yours are outrageous and lack any logic and compliance, and are far removed from fair and just trade, because all the mandatory details and filings of a proper COMMERCIAL seller cost money, so please think first before writing when you at least have some idea of the matter, sorry but you’ll have to swallow that.
turbotuentchen
immediately regulates all PRIVATE sellers according to the legal requirements, 30 items and/or €2000 per year. (collection liquidators, heirs, etc. excluded)
uhm, 🙄
which law says that private sellers are only allowed to sell 30 items or only for 2000 euros a year?
"the new EU law" ver. 2.0 ???
ah, the commercial-privates are all collection liquidators or estate splitters, whose ads sometimes are so touching to read 😇
trading-and-more
OPHmm, ever heard of the Platform Transparency Act?? just google it
Well, it is the responsibility of eBay to regulate this and also to check it with proof, when it comes to inheritances and large collections, it would be too easy to just claim, collection liquidation and/or estate, without evidence, photos, purchase receipts from back in the day, etc.
It is a fact that the PRIVATE COMMERCIAL sellers are demonstrably responsible for drastic drops in sales for the honest commercial sellers. Selling for nothing under flimsy claims must be stopped immediately.
All those who think something else are the ones who sell black under the radar for cash in hand and think; they are the greatest, that has to be said.
By this I do not mean the honest PRIVATE sellers in general, but the many black sheep with, as I said, up to 20,000 listings, does that have anything to do with PRIVATE??, rather not
bootyooty
Sorry if I vehemently disagree with that... I've been on eBay since 2003, and there were already plenty of private commercial sellers back then. That didn't stop these sellers from selling here either, and back then a sales commission had to be paid!
There was no Platform Tax Transparency Act back then, and accordingly there were no numerous threads like "I’m supposed to register as a business", and those threads are now piling up here.
Antitrust warnings can and may be sent by any seller here, can't they?
So if one of them has 20,000 items, then can't that be reported? Possibly also to the tax authorities, if they care.
And no, collections span years or are inherited — how is the heir supposed to prove that the deceased started collecting, and when?
At most they can prove that they are the heir of the deceased, and that's already it.
I can understand that commercial sellers get annoyed here about quite a few things, including fees, etc. If masses of new goods are being sold by private sellers, I stay well clear of that too
I also don't really see a boom since eBay waived sales commission for private sellers.
On the contrary... since sellers have had to process payments through eBay, there have been more and more threads where private sellers say goodbye here because there are always buyers who abuse buyer protection and then sellers may end up losing both money and goods.
trading-and-more
OPbootyooty your comment
Sorry if I vehemently disagree with that... I've been on eBay since 2003 and even back then there were plenty of private-commercial sellers. That didn't stop this seller back then from selling here either, and back then selling commissions still had to be paid!
There was no Platform Tax Transparency Act back then, and accordingly there were also no numerous threads like "I’m supposed to register as a business", and those threads are piling up here now.
but what you don't get is that the difference was BACK THEN there was no financial advantage for private sellers !!!!! Same fees - almost fair competition regardless of the tax burden that a commercial seller had then and has/had today. Today a commercial seller pays almost 30% of the sale price with all commissions and listing fees, and a PRIVATE COMMERCIAL seller 0% is that fair competition? probably not, if you have a different opinion on that, then you are or can't be from this world.
Can and may every trader here send competition-law warnings?
If there’s someone with 20,000 items, then you can report that, right? If necessary, also to the tax authorities, if they’re interested at all.
Hmm, good point about the warnings, you think I don't know that? Should a reputable seller first have to commission dozens of warnings through a lawyer every day at their own expense?? Or take the time to do that, make test purchases to get all the names and addresses, and then contact the responsible tax office and wait for such guys to maliciously attack your business account, destroy it, and then cowardly scratch your car every second day and/or puncture the tires??
It would be easier if enay would make everything fair and just again, commissions for everyone and accounts limited to 30 sales and/or €2000 turnover.
Your statement regarding inheritance and collections, hello, that can be proven: with an inheritance there is a certificate of inheritance, and with collections there are contemporaries who can declare such things under oath, because you need that in a traceable way for the tax office too; therefore it is also possible to inform eBay of this in advance, voluntarily and/or disclose it in the event of a warning.
I can understand that commercial dealers get annoyed here about one thing or another, including the fees etc. If masses of new goods are sold by private sellers, I avoid that too
I also don't really see a boom since eBay waived the selling commission for private sellers.
Ah, you can understand when dealers are annoyed...
Hello, understanding and going bankrupt are two different things. The private-commercial sellers can sell much cheaper, why?? They pay no commissions, have a 30% advantage over the reputable commercial sellers- And you, when you buy something, where do you buy?? right, where it's cheaper.
Result: decline in sales up to bankruptcy, and eBay goes to the dogs in the process too, because there are no commissions anymore. END OF STORY
Open your eyes, and comment on this here
voli-maus
Negative ratings for buyers were often just revenge ratings, @trading-and-more .
I still have texts like this in my head: buyer did not leave feedback. That rating was then red.
They abolished that, so you can no longer rate buyers negatively.
Why?
The buyers were rated negatively because they hadn’t rated the seller.
How pointless is that?
And if a buyer gets a positive with negative text, then as a seller I’m not protected from that user buying something from me.
Why?
I offer an item for sale on eBay and only see at the first bidding attempt or after the purchase who bid or bought from me.
I have two accounts, one for buying, one for selling, @trading-and-more .
Just so you know.
trading-and-more
OPHello, it's really incredible what examples you're citing there, or have in mind. Sure, there have been one or two questionable ratings from sellers, but there were and are countless ratings from buyers that still stand against that to this day and are becoming more and more numerous every day.
The fact is that rating means rating, no ifs or buts, either everyone can rate honestly, fairly and realistically and/or no one.
On which other platform/rating systems is it like on eBay??
Please give some well-known examples, and not vague statements like that's how I still remember it.
Or give me your definition of what rating means
Thanks
hasjana
◇◇◆◇◇◆◇◇◆◇◇
yeah ... I’d also recommend googling it and then actually reading and understanding what you found
Private individuals are בהחלט allowed to make more than 30 sales and/or generate more than 2000 euros in revenue
the law only includes the reporting obligation for sellers who have reached these thresholds within a calendar year
trading-and-more
OPHello, you seem to understand everything, but not the Platform Transparency Act
What happens if you sell more than 30 items and/or make €2000 in revenue you have to verify your account and after the end of the year you will be reported with your complete transactions.
Now, if you sell your poetry picture collection or your angel collection, you can certainly explain yourself to the tax office, but if someone has 20000 items on and has sold tens of thousands of items, new, used, vintage, retro, antique and so on, then they have a problem!!! or!!
And then it is the case that during this time they acted as a PRIVATE COMMERCIAL seller without commissions and all legal requirements as a COMMERCIAL seller, and that during this time it was UNLAWFUL in the first place and it was unfair trading compared to the honest sellers, or???
Therefore ebay, which sees everything in such PRIVATE COMMERCIAL cases, should or must react immediately and reclimate you to 30 items and/or €2000, except in the case of verifiable COLLECTIONS and/or estates.
END
trading-and-more
OPWell, first of all, Happy New Year!!
On the topic of improvement/change suggestions!!
What does rating mean?? What is a rating portal supposed to reflect and/or what should something like that look like?
Rating means objectively describing the positive and/or negative experience with a buyer and/or seller; this should serve to protect buyers/sellers from any “bad apples” and/or make it easier to decide whether to buy/sell.
But what does the EBAY RATING SYSTEM have to do with that?? basically nothing, right??
Because, in fact, only the buyer can rate, and however they want: NEUTRAL, POSITIVE and/or NEGATIVE.
Some buyers use this system as leverage to enforce their will/wishes against the seller, (of course as a seller you can take action against that and report it and blah blah blah, file a request for removal, etc., which may or may not then be removed) but that really should not be the case, because buyers know that when the seller rates, they can ONLY rate POSITIVELY!!! Rate POSITIVELY with NEGATIVE content, and perhaps an honest experience, is meanwhile almost always deleted at the buyer's request. Is that fair, is that just, is that honest rating?? NO, it isn't.
Why can't one rate as it actually was?? Buyer doesn't pay - negative (possibly after cancellation of the transaction automatically red dot by eBay, BUYER DOESN'T PAY!!) Buyer lies, makes false claims, buyer tries to scam a partial refund, buyer opens a case and claims defective, incomplete just to scam a return label and and and
I think if the rating system were reformed in this regard, many buyers would change their behavior, nobody wants to be exposed publicly as a “non-payer” “unreliable” and/or liar, and sellers are able to decide based on the honest ratings whether I sell and/or accept the price suggestion or not.
Everyone must be able and allowed to rate as the transaction warrants,
Why is there a distinction between buyer and seller?? is that legally covered, is that discriminatory?? in any case it is not FAIR, and it needs to be changed
Regards ;-))
bootyooty
Yes, and likewise.
Nope, I see it differently, and since you've only been around since 2017, I'll link you to the change from back then in 2008, which definitely wasn't made for no reason. (if a buyer makes additional demands, etc., you report that to eBay)
UPDATED: Changes to the feedback system
Thursday, May 22, 2008 | 5:53 PM CET
Dear eBay members,
we already announced the changes to the eBay feedback system to you on May 7 in an eBay News.
These changes to the feedback system are now in effect.
Details about the changes can be found on our information page. Also visit our feedback forum. There you can discuss the changes with other eBay members.
Kind regards
Your eBay team
Dear eBay members,
we already announced various changes to the eBay feedback system at the beginning of the year. We will implement these changes from mid-May. In this eBay News you will find details about the changes. At the same time, we would also like to explain to you the reasons for the changes to the feedback system.
What will change as of around May 22?
Why have these changes become necessary?
Feedback is a basis for strangers to exchange money and goods with trust. Buyers in particular depend on feedback from their predecessors that is as honest as possible. For a long time this system worked very well and the feedback reflected the reliability of eBay sellers.
As the marketplace has evolved, the feedback behavior of eBay members has changed, and buyers often have not left honest feedback even after a bad buying experience for fear of retaliatory feedback. This made it harder for other buyers to distinguish between truly good and less trustworthy sellers. In addition, many buyers who once received negative feedback in retaliation have turned their backs on the eBay marketplace. Ultimately, this harms sellers on eBay and the marketplace as a whole.
With the changes to the feedback system, we are now ensuring that it will continue to be the trust-building tool in trading on eBay. But we are also taking into account general developments in e-commerce, where usually only the seller is rated. The fact that neutral feedback will now also be included in the calculation of the share of positive feedback is another logical step toward capturing actual buying experiences in the feedback system. This will steadily reduce the number of negative buying experiences.
This also fits with the fact that especially PowerSellers, as eBay's best commercial sellers, will in future have to meet even stricter (feedback) standards in order to participate in the PowerSeller program:
For buyers who purchase from a PowerSeller, the risk of a negative buying experience is therefore kept within very narrow limits.
We will observe and analyze very carefully how the changes to the feedback system affect trade on eBay and the marketplace as a whole, and will make further adjustments if this should become necessary.
How can sellers protect themselves against unjustified negative feedback?
In recent weeks and months, we have discussed the feedback changes in many conversations with buyers and sellers. It became clear that sellers need to be better protected than before against arbitrary feedback from buyers. Based on suggestions from the eBay community, we will additionally introduce the following improvements:
All of this underscores the importance of the feedback system and the growing responsibility of buyers when leaving feedback. The aforementioned abolition of mutual withdrawal also prevents negative feedback from being handled too lightly. For buyers, it will then also not be possible to first leave negative feedback and pressure the seller with the prospect of withdrawal.
For sellers, feedback remains important and useful, as it represents a small but indispensable thank-you to every buyer who pays for their purchased item on time and has behaved fairly toward the seller.
We are convinced that these changes will strengthen the feedback system as a trust-building tool. Buyers will have the opportunity to leave honest feedback, and sellers will be protected from arbitrary ratings.
Also visit our feedback forum, where you can discuss the changes with other buyers and sellers.
Kind regards
Your eBay team
trading-and-more
OPHello, now you seem to be justifying and defending that, but no matter how you argue it, it’s not fair and not just. Everyone should/must agree with me on this point.
It’s a one-sided assessment, certainly not fair; everyone must have the option to give their objective opinion on the respective transaction, neutrally, positively and also negatively, that’s how it is with almost all rating systems, where can you only rate positively??? Name me some notable and plausible examples, please.
By the way, I think I’ve been on eBay much longer than you probably will have been, I’m one of the first-hour members, I think since 1997/98, and I experienced the whole development of eBay there. At first I used eBay with joy, today, well, we see where we all stand; unfortunately little has remained from the beginning. It was made into what it is today, made worse to improve it, to put it bluntly, without looking through an eBay-brille.
The old-timers like me on eBay will certainly nod in agreement.
There’s really something to the motto Never change a running system, so the more things were changed, the more it certainly only got a tiny bit better, and/or was beneficial to the system and its users.
All of this is not criticism, but a clear statement without ifs or buts.
Best regards